Dodgy data and inaccurate reporting!


An interesting article on Penzance and housing this last week on ‘It’s Our Cornwall’

The Cornishman reported this week that “Penzance has fewest affordable homes compared to applicants”. Except that it doesn’t. The headline is wrong. Sure, local people in Penzance and all Cornish towns need cheaper housing. A pity however that this sloppy reporting didn’t bother to check the facts.

Quite.  The media are apt to repeat any old assertion that is thrown up.  Stories it would appear are based on someones press release where facts are avoided or selected to support the story.     Members of the public are at a disadvantage when it comes to assessing news ‘reports’.  How do they know if the facts are correct or not?  How much more lies behind the story which is not discussed?  Is the article just repeating a story from a particular group or organisation?  Does it include any critical analysis or dissection of the evidence?

There are many news reports which fail abysmally to present a meaningful picture of a situation.

How many people accept that if a newspaper article states that x thousand jobs will be created then it must be  a fact?

What is implied by extra jobs?  People might assume they are additional in the sense of  more jobs for the existing population, not simply jobs to meet the demand from extra jobseekers.

How many people have a clear idea what the Homechoice Register  (wrongly referred to as the ‘waiting list’), actually is?  They might get the impression that there are 27,000 households all living in intolerable conditions.

What do people think when they hear that a site which is to be developed is brownfield?   They probably envisage an area devoid of vegetation, old wrecked industrial buildings and the like.  They might be surprised to find that many sites referred to as brownfield include substantial areas of greenfield – including actual green fields!

What should people do?   Check the report don’t accept it as ‘fact’.  Is there an alternative source of information.   Challenge things if they do not look right.  If you know an area check it out.

Real debate and discussion in a democracy cannot succeed without access to information!

Advertisements

2 comments on “Dodgy data and inaccurate reporting!

  1. Craig Weatherhill says:

    No mention in the “newspaper” report of the number of 2nd homes in the area. No mention of the number of empty properties in the area, and when Dwelly laments that only 14 affordable homes were built in the last 12 month period, no mention of the fact that Mrs Dwelly is Head of Affordable Housing at Kremlin Kernow! Not just sloppy reporting. Dishonest reporting.

  2. ruthlewarne says:

    Then there’s the fact that Tim Dwelly, the new Cornwall Cllr promoting this stuff, is MARRIED TO THE HEAD OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING!!!! The Cornishman is withholding this information from the public.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s